[Matthias Noll: "Re-recorded old Testament tracks -- yawn. Two with Zetro -- yeah right, so who gives a damn? Hadn't a friend of mine bought this, I would have never been tempted to check it out. And I would have screwed up big time! In Paul (R.I.P.) Baloff's words: this is older than shit, heavier than time! For me "Reign of Terror" is the best of the eleven tracks and I can't stop fantasizing about how cool _The Legacy_ would have sounded with the ripping and snarling Steve Souza hadn't he joined Exodus. If you've got the slightest interest in thrash metal, then go get this now, set the volume to eleven, fall to your knees and bow to these Thrash Lords!"]

[Paul Schwarz: "New performances with a modern production of _Legacy_-era Testament sounded like a recipe for excellence. And despite the fact that the new "Over the Wall" is sadly no match for its thirteen-year-old original, almost every single one of these new versions improves on its original, with "Disciples of the Watch" the crushingly reworked highlight."]